Sullivan's Island SC Real Estate and Community Guide
Home prices, the stations from Fort Moultrie to Breach Inlet, the front beach and the protected accreted land, schools, taxes, flood insurance and the island's long-standing ban on short-term rentals, built from closed MLS sales since January 2023.
What this guide covers
Sullivan's Island is the small barrier island between Mount Pleasant and the Isle of Palms, with Charleston Harbor and Fort Moultrie at one end and Breach Inlet at the other. It is its own town, it is almost all houses, and it does not allow short-term vacation rentals, so the people buying here are planning to live in the house or keep it in the family. You get Middle Street, the lighthouse, a wide beach with a protected maritime forest behind part of it, and an easy drive to Mount Pleasant and downtown. The trade-offs: very few homes come up for sale, prices start around $3 million for a house, the town reviews what you can build, and flood and insurance questions have to be run address by address.
How we define Sullivan's Island here: every closed single-family detached and attached (townhome and condo) sale in the CHS Regional MLS in MLS area 43 (Sullivan's Island), from January 1, 2023 to November 21, 2026. Area 43 lines up with the island itself: every sale in it has a Sullivan's Island address in zip code 29482 and the Town of Sullivan's Island tax district, and I found no Sullivan's Island or 29482 home sales filed under any other MLS area. I left out three fractional-ownership sales (shares of one house on I'On Avenue), and lots, land and boat slips are not included.
That comes to 146 closed sales since January 2023 (143 houses and 3 condos), ranging from $890,000 to $19,000,000, with a median of $4,225,000.
A note on medians: unless a line says "houses only," every median here covers all home types together, and "2026 YTD" means January 1 to November 21, 2026. Sullivan's is almost all houses, so the all-types and houses-only numbers are close. With only 30 to 40 sales a year, one or two big closings can move a median, so I show the sample size next to every number.
Headline stats
Jan. 1 to Nov. 21, 2026. Single-family detached and attached homes in MLS area 43, Sullivan's Island. Source: CHS Regional MLS via Flexmls.
Key takeaways
Prices are up from last year, mostly because bigger houses sold.
The all-types median was $4,100,000 from Jan. 1 to Nov. 21, 2025 (30 sales) and is $4,750,000 so far in 2026 (35 sales). Average price per square foot barely moved, $1,642 to $1,655, while the median house that sold grew from about 3,140 to about 3,700 square feet.
2026 is already the biggest dollar year in this window.
$206 million has closed on the island so far this year, more than any full year since 2023 ($165 million in 2023, $203 million in 2024 and $169 million in 2025).
The under-$3 million house has nearly disappeared.
15 sales closed under $3 million in 2023, 13 in 2024, 9 in 2025 and 2 so far in 2026, and nothing has closed between $2 million and $3 million this year. 33 of the 35 sales in 2026 were $3 million or more.
Buyers have more time than they did in 2023.
The median home took 58 days to sell in 2026, up from 29 in 2023. No 2026 sale closed over list price, sales averaged 95.0% of list and 92.1% of original list, and there are about 9.1 months of supply.
The front beach carries the premium.
Since 2023, the 16 houses the MLS tags as beachfront have a median of $8,775,000 and a median of $2,116 a foot. The 115 houses with no water tag at all have a median of $3,900,000 and $1,382 a foot.
This is not a rental island.
The town prohibits vacation rentals (any paid stay under 28 days), and only rentals that were operating before November 21, 2000 can continue. If you need rental income to make the numbers work, Sullivan's is the wrong island.
Sullivan's Island at a glance
| Location | A barrier island in Charleston County, SC, between Mount Pleasant and the Isle of Palms, with Charleston Harbor and Fort Moultrie at the southwest end and Breach Inlet at the northeast end |
| Local government | Town of Sullivan's Island. Tax District 23 (Town of Sullivan's Island). Town Hall at 2056 Middle St. |
| Zip code | 29482 |
| MLS area | 43 (Sullivan's Island) |
| Median sale price, 2026 YTD (Jan. 1 to Nov. 21) | $4,750,000 all types; $5,025,000 houses only (MLS) |
| Homes sold since Jan. 2023 | 146 (MLS): 143 houses and 3 condos |
| Pockets | Most sales are filed as "Sullivans Island" or with no subdivision name, so I group them by station number from the address, from the Fort Moultrie end to Breach Inlet (see Neighborhoods) |
| Public schools | Charleston County School District. The town lists Sullivan's Island Elementary, Laing Middle and Moultrie Middle, and Wando High as the public schools that serve the island. Confirm by address |
| Landmarks | Fort Moultrie (National Park Service, 1214 Middle St.), the Charleston Light (the Sullivan's Island lighthouse, first lit in 1962), the beach and the town's protected accreted land and maritime forest |
| Drive times from Town Hall (2056 Middle St.) | Shem Creek 9 to 16 min, downtown (King and Calhoun) 18 to 35 min, MUSC 20 to 40 min, CHS airport 24 to 40 min (Google Maps, typical for an 8 a.m. weekday start; see Commute) |
| Flood insurance | Town of Sullivan's Island is FEMA CRS Class 5 (up to 25% off eligible NFIP policies) on FEMA's October 1, 2026 list. Check the parcel and ask for an elevation certificate |
| Property tax rate | 275.0 mills in the Town of Sullivan's Island (District 23) (2026) |
| Short-term rentals | Vacation rentals of fewer than 28 days are prohibited, except for a small number of rentals that were operating before November 2000. Read Taxes and rules |

Sullivan's Island market report by year
Closed single-family detached and attached sales, all types together, in MLS area 43. 2026 runs through November 21.
| Year | Homes sold | Median price | Avg $/sq ft | Median days on market | Avg sale-to-list | Sold over list | $3M+ sales | $5M+ sales | $10M+ sales | Total volume |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 39 | $3,800,000 | $1,395 | 29 | 95.2% | 10% (4) | 24 | 11 | 1 | $165M |
| 2024 | 40 | $4,590,000 | $1,682 | 22 | 96.1% | 3% (1) | 27 | 19 | 4 | $203M |
| 2025 | 32 | $4,100,000 | $1,613 | 40 | 95.9% | 6% (2) | 23 | 13 | 4 | $169M |
| 2026 YTD | 35 | $4,750,000 | $1,655 | 58 | 95.0% | 0% (0) | 33 | 17 | 4 | $206M |
Every sale in this window except two Island House condos was $1 million or more: 144 of 146 since 2023, including 34 of 35 in 2026.
Source: CHS Regional MLS via Flexmls, closed single-family detached and attached sales. 2026 runs through Nov. 21.
Source: CHS Regional MLS via Flexmls, closed single-family detached and attached sales. 2026 runs through Nov. 21.
Source: CHS Regional MLS via Flexmls, closed single-family detached and attached sales. 2026 runs through Nov. 21.
Source: CHS Regional MLS via Flexmls, closed single-family detached and attached sales. 2026 runs through Nov. 21.
What I see in this: Sullivan's trades 30 to 40 homes a year, so it is a thin market and the yearly median jumps around with whichever houses happened to sell. Price per foot is the steadier read. It jumped from about $1,400 in 2023 to about $1,680 in 2024 and has held in the $1,600s since. What changed is speed and leverage. In 2023 a tenth of sales went over list and the median home sold in about a month. This year nothing has gone over list, the median is about two months, and there are more than nine months of supply on the market. That is a buyer who can take their time, not a falling market. The houses that are priced right and well located are still trading at about 95% of list. The ones that are not are sitting.
Houses vs. condos, 2026 YTD
| Type | Homes sold | Median price | Avg $/sq ft | Median days on market | Months of supply |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single-family detached | 34 | $5,025,000 | $1,670 | 65 | 9.0 |
| Single-family attached (condos) | 1 | $894,000 | $1,152 | 17 | Not meaningful |
Sullivan's is a house market. Only three condos sold on the island in almost four years, two of them in the Island House building at 2057 Middle Street and one in an older building on I'On Avenue. If a condo comes up, it is the only way onto the island under $2 million.

What your budget buys in Sullivan's Island
Source: CHS Regional MLS via Flexmls, closed single-family detached and attached sales. 2026 runs through Nov. 21.
Closed sales on Sullivan's Island since January 2023, by price band, with the 2026 YTD count alongside. I am using the full window here because 35 sales in one year is too few to say much about each band. Treat these as a snapshot of what actually closed, not a promise of what will be listed next month.
| Price band | Sales since 2023 | Share | 2026 YTD | Median size | Median beds | Typical year built | Median lot | Mostly |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $2M | 9 | 6% | 2 | 1,744 sq ft | 2 | 1930 | 0.20 acre | The three condos plus small older cottages, often on smaller lots |
| $2M to $3M | 30 | 21% | 0 | 1,690 sq ft | 3 | 1931 | 0.36 acre | Older cottages, many on big lots |
| $3M to $5M | 47 | 32% | 16 | 2,931 sq ft | 4 | 1963 | 0.36 acre | The middle of the market: renovated older houses and some newer ones |
| $5M to $8M | 38 | 26% | 10 | 4,009 sq ft | 5 | 2012 | 0.47 acre | Newer or fully rebuilt houses, some on the water |
| $8M+ | 22 | 15% | 7 | 4,456 sq ft | 5 | 2017 | 0.51 acre | Front beach and deep-water marsh lots, most built since 2000 |
Under $2M: Nine sales in almost four years. Three were condos (two at Island House, 2057 Middle Street, at $890,000 and $894,000, and one at 1766 I'On Avenue at $1,375,000). The houses were small, older cottages, such as the 1,000 square foot house at 409 Station 22 1/2 Street that sold for $1,550,000 in September 2026. One sale in this band, 2102 Atlantic Avenue at $1,995,000, looks unusual for its size and is flagged in the claims list.
$2M to $3M: This used to be the way into a house on Sullivan's. Thirty sold since 2023, typically about 1,700 square feet with three bedrooms and built around 1930. None has closed in this band in 2026. Many of these were lot-value sales, where the buyer is paying for the land and the right to renovate or rebuild under the town's rules.
$3M to $5M: The biggest band, 47 sales and 16 of this year's 35. A mix of renovated older houses and some newer ones, typically about 2,900 square feet with four bedrooms.
$5M to $8M: Newer or rebuilt houses, about 4,000 square feet with five bedrooms, median year built 2012. A few are on the marsh or the front beach.
$8M+: Twenty-two sales since 2023, seven of them this year. Nine of the 22 are tagged beachfront and three marshfront, and most were built since 2000.
Sullivan's Island neighborhoods
Sullivan's does not break down into MLS subdivision names. Of the 146 sales since January 2023, 88 are filed simply as "Sullivans Island," 54 have no subdivision name, three say Marshall Reservation and one says Island House. So I group sales by station. Locals give directions by station number, and Sullivan's house numbers roughly track them, so 2200 Middle Street is around Station 22. I took the station from the first two digits of each street number (or from the street name for addresses like Station 22 1/2 Street) and split the island into four stretches. Two addresses (3 Florence Street and 405 Seabreeze Lane) could not be placed this way and are left out of the pocket rows. Medians are all types together, January 1, 2023 to November 21, 2026.
| Sales | Median price | Median $/sq ft | Median size | Median year built | Median lot | 2026 YTD sales | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fort Moultrie end, up to Station 15 | 19 | $4,200,000 | $1,329 | 3,394 sq ft | 1985 | 0.27 acre | 3 |
| Stations 16 to 22 | 47 | $3,425,000 | $1,321 | 2,886 sq ft | 1973 | 0.38 acre | 10 |
| Stations 23 to 28 | 57 | $4,750,000 | $1,625 | 3,581 sq ft | 1985 | 0.51 acre | 14 |
| Station 29 to Breach Inlet | 21 | $5,250,000 | $1,652 | 3,511 sq ft | 2002 | 0.36 acre | 6 |
| Houses tagged beachfront (any station) | 16 | $8,775,000 | $2,116 | 4,255 sq ft | 1993 | 0.47 acre | 4 |
| Houses with no water tag (any station) | 115 | $3,900,000 | $1,382 | 3,361 sq ft | 1977 | 0.40 acre | 27 |
The beachfront and no-water rows overlap the station rows; they are there to show the front-beach premium. "Beachfront" is a checkbox the listing agent fills in, not a survey, and some of those houses face the town's protected accreted land rather than open sand (more on that below). By street, houses on Atlantic Avenue have a median of $6,000,000 (17 sales), I'On Avenue $4,025,000 (28), Jasper Boulevard $4,125,000 (12), Myrtle Avenue $3,800,000 (11) and Middle Street $3,562,500 (30).
Jan. 1, 2023 to Nov. 21, 2026. Station rows are grouped by house number, which tracks the island's station numbers; water rows compare houses the listing agent tagged beachfront with houses that have no water tag. Source: CHS Regional MLS via Flexmls.
Pockets I watch closely
The Fort Moultrie end. Below Station 16 the island runs toward Fort Moultrie and the harbor, on streets like Middle Street, Poe, Thompson, Osceola, Cove and Conquest Avenues. This is the end with harbor and marsh views, and lots tend to be smaller here (median 0.27 acre). The National Park Service notes that the Fort Moultrie Military Reservation once covered much of the island, which is part of why this end has so many older houses. 1420 Thompson Avenue, on deep water, sold for $10,375,000 in April 2024.
Stations 16 to 22, the middle of the island. This stretch has the most older houses (18 of its 47 sales were built before 1950) and includes the island's small business district on Middle Street around Station 22 and Town Hall at 2056 Middle Street. It also has the most affordable house sales on the island, with a median of $3,425,000. On the ocean side, the Atlantic Avenue houses between about Station 16 and Station 18 sit behind the widest part of the protected accreted land and the maritime forest, so "front row" here can mean a long walk through the trees to the water.
Stations 23 to 28. The biggest group of sales, 57 since 2023, with the largest lots on the island (median 0.51 acre) and a median of $4,750,000. This is where many of the half-acre lots on I'On, Myrtle and Atlantic Avenues and the Goldbug, Raven and Bayonne side streets are, and it includes front beach sales such as 2529 Atlantic Avenue ($13,500,000) and 2407 Atlantic Avenue ($13,000,000) in 2025, plus marsh lots on Raven Drive.
Station 29 to Breach Inlet. The newest houses on the island (median year built 2002) and the highest median of the four stretches, $5,250,000. Marshall Boulevard and Jasper Boulevard run up toward Breach Inlet and the bridge to the Isle of Palms. The island's top sale since 2023, 3308 Jasper Boulevard at $19,000,000, is up here on the marsh side, as is 2879 Marshall Boulevard, a new house on the front beach that sold for $14,000,000 in February 2026.


Notable Sullivan's Island sales since 2023
The 10 highest closed sales on Sullivan's Island from January 1, 2023 to November 21, 2026. Prices are the closed price in the MLS.
| Close date | Address | Closed price | List price | DOM | Beds / baths | Sq ft | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct. 7, 2026 | 3308 Jasper Blvd. | $19,000,000 | $22,350,000 | 130 | 6 / 6.5 | 5,829 | 2017 |
| Feb. 20, 2026 | 2879 Marshall Blvd. | $14,000,000 | $14,750,000 | 22 | 5 / 5.5 | 3,911 | 2026 |
| Apr. 10, 2025 | 2529 Atlantic Ave. | $13,500,000 | $13,500,000 | 5 | 6 / 4.5 | 4,658 | 1985 |
| Oct. 14, 2025 | 2407 Atlantic Ave. | $13,000,000 | $14,000,000 | 106 | 5 / 6.0 | 5,106 | 1975 |
| Aug. 7, 2025 | 3304 Jasper Blvd. | $12,500,000 | $12,500,000 | 0 | 5 / 5.0 | 3,708 | 2001 |
| June 21, 2024 | 2630 Raven Dr. | $11,500,000 | $11,500,000 | 0 | 4 / 5.5 | 5,086 | 2019 |
| Aug. 6, 2024 | 1745 Atlantic Ave. | $11,500,000 | $11,900,000 | 13 | 5 / 6.0 | 4,550 | 2024 |
| Feb. 6, 2025 | 3213 Middle St. | $10,500,000 | $10,995,000 | 32 | 6 / 6.5 | 4,160 | 2023 |
| Apr. 30, 2024 | 1420 Thompson Ave. | $10,375,000 | $10,375,000 | 6 | 4 / 3.5 | 3,394 | 2009 |
| Jan. 10, 2024 | 1755 Atlantic Ave. | $10,300,000 | $10,495,000 | 12 | 5 / 5.5 | 4,418 | 2023 |
None of the top 10 closed over its final list price. Four closed at list. Two show 0 days on market, which usually means the sale was put together before the listing went into the MLS. 3213 Middle Street also sold in March 2023 for $7,950,000, so it appears in this window twice.
Living on Sullivan's Island
Quieter, fancier, and the read from my video (my take)
In my pros and cons video I put it this way: Sullivan's Island is quieter and fancier. It feels more like a neighborhood, a little more polished, and homes for sale there are few and far between, and they're very pricey. On a nice Saturday it still gets plenty busy, but the vibe stays pretty relaxed. Someone who falls for Folly's energy might find Sullivan's a little too buttoned up, and a Sullivan's buyer might find Folly louder than they like. That is a good test to run on yourself before you shop here.
It is also my personal favorite beach, and I said so in my $1 million video. Part of what you pay for in South Mount Pleasant is being a few minutes from it.
On the numbers, Sullivan's is a patient market right now. Very few homes trade, price per foot has held, and buyers have time to look: no 2026 sale closed over list price, and the median home took 58 days to sell.
Video: The Unexpected Pros and Cons of Living in Charleston, SC (starts at Sullivan's Island, 15:37)
Middle Street, the beach, Fort Moultrie and the lighthouse
Middle Street is the island's main street, and its small business district sits around Station 22, near Town Hall at 2056 Middle Street. Most of daily life is the beach. The town's beach rules are worth reading before you move: there are no lifeguards, every dog needs a town license (residents and visitors), alcohol is not allowed on the beach, beach paths or streets, smoking is banned on the beach, beach paths and public spaces, and visitors have to park in the right of way with all four tires off the pavement (Town of Sullivan's Island, beach rules).
Fort Moultrie, at 1214 Middle Street, is part of Fort Sumter and Fort Moultrie National Historical Park. The first fort here, built of palmetto logs and sand, turned back a British fleet on June 28, 1776. The Charleston Light, the triangular black and white lighthouse most people just call the Sullivan's Island lighthouse, was dedicated on June 15, 1962, and the Park Service describes it as the last major lighthouse built in the United States.
Schools
Sullivan's Island students are in the Charleston County School District. Sullivan's Island Elementary is on the island and serves Sullivan's Island and the Isle of Palms, and it is also a partial magnet school. The town lists Laing Middle and Moultrie Middle for grades 6 to 8 and Wando High for grades 9 to 12 (Town of Sullivan's Island, schools). School zones can change. Always confirm the zone for a specific address with the CCSD school lookup.
South Carolina's 2025-26 report cards, released in October 2026, which rate schools Excellent, Good, Average, Below Average or Unsatisfactory:
| School | Grades | 2025-26 rating |
|---|---|---|
| Sullivan's Island Elementary | Pre-K to 5 | Excellent (70) |
| Laing Middle | 6 to 8 | Excellent (64) |
| Moultrie Middle | 6 to 8 | Excellent (63) |
| Wando High | 9 to 12 | Excellent (84) |
All four ratings come from the South Carolina Department of Education's 2025-26 report card data, released in October 2026. Ratings are a snapshot of one year, not a reason to choose a street.
Commute and getting on and off the island
There are two ways off Sullivan's: the Ben Sawyer Bridge (SC 703, Ben Sawyer Boulevard) over the Intracoastal Waterway to Mount Pleasant, and the bridge over Breach Inlet to the Isle of Palms. The Ben Sawyer is a swing bridge that opens for boats under federal drawbridge rules (33 CFR Part 117), so every so often you wait.
These are typical drive times from Google Maps for a departure at 8 a.m. on Tuesday, November 24, 2026. The first "typically" range and the first mileage are what I am using. A summer Saturday with beach traffic on Ben Sawyer Boulevard will not look like a midweek November morning, so treat these as a quiet-day baseline.
From 2056 Middle St. (Sullivan's Island Town Hall):
| Destination | Typical time | Miles | Usual route in this run |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shem Creek Park, Mount Pleasant | 9 to 16 min | 4.8 | SC 703 (Ben Sawyer Blvd.) |
| Mount Pleasant Towne Centre | 12 to 20 min | 6.2 | SC 703 (Ben Sawyer Blvd.) |
| Downtown Charleston (King Street and Calhoun Street) | 18 to 35 min | 9.7 | SC 703 and the Ravenel Bridge |
| MUSC (171 Ashley Avenue) | 20 to 40 min | 10.0 | SC 703 and the Ravenel Bridge |
| Charleston International Airport | 24 to 40 min | 18.5 | SC 703 and I-26 W |
Flood zones, the accreted land and the beach
Sullivan's Island is a barrier island, and flood risk is part of buying here. Check the parcel, not a neighborhood rule of thumb, and ask for an elevation certificate.
FEMA's list of Community Rating System communities effective October 1, 2026 shows the Town of Sullivan's Island (NFIP 455418) as Class 5, which is a 25% discount on eligible NFIP policies, with a current effective date of May 1, 2017 (FEMA, Community Rating System). FEMA's Community Status Book lists the town's current flood map date as January 29, 2021. That is the same class as the Isle of Palms (Class 5) and better than the City of Charleston (Class 6) on the same list.
Unlike most barrier islands, Sullivan's has grown. SiP Magazine traces it to the Charleston Harbor jetties finished in 1890, which push sand toward the island. In 1991 the town put its remaining undeveloped beachfront land into a conservation easement with the Lowcountry Open Land Trust. SiP put that land at 87 acres in 1991 and over 190 acres when it walked the forest, much of it now a maritime forest whose bulk lies between Station 18 and Fort Moultrie (SiP Magazine). The deed requires the land to stay in its natural state, with limited trimming allowed for things like mosquito control, public access and views.
How much the town can trim has been in court since 2010. In February 2026 the South Carolina Court of Appeals agreed with the town that a 2020 settlement calling for selective thinning was invalid (Court of Appeals Opinion 6139). The South Carolina Supreme Court agreed to hear the homeowners' appeal in August 2026, and briefing finished in October; as of November 21, 2026, no decision had been posted (SC Supreme Court docket 2026-001038). If you are buying on Atlantic Avenue or anywhere next to the accreted land, do not assume the view or the path to the water you see today is the one you will have in ten years. Walk it, and we will look at the plat and the deed together.
HOAs
Most of Sullivan's has no HOA. Only 13% of sales since 2023 have an association flag in the MLS, and that includes all three condos. I did not pull association fee amounts, and I am not going to invent them. If the house you like has a flag, get the documents and read the rules.

Taxes and rules
South Carolina property tax: 4% vs. 6%
South Carolina assesses owner-occupied legal residences at 4% and most other residential property at 6%. If the Sullivan's Island home is not your legal residence, expect the 6% rate. That includes most second homes. Run the address through the county estimator, and talk with the Charleston County Auditor about legal residence if that applies to you.
Town millage on Sullivan's Island (2026, Charleston County)
Sullivan's Island is its own town. For 2026, Charleston County's millage card shows 218.8 mills countywide plus 56.2 mills for the Town of Sullivan's Island, or 275.0 mills in Tax District 23.
Rough example from the county's 2026 tax estimator, $4,000,000 taxable value, District 23, stormwater 0, including the $154 user fee and the credits the estimator applies: about $16,682 at the 4% legal-residence rate and about $61,914 at the 6% rate. At $500,000 the same estimator came to about $2,220 and $7,874. Those are examples, not tax bills. Run the specific address at the Charleston County tax estimator.
Short-term rentals
This is the biggest difference between Sullivan's and the Isle of Palms next door. The town's zoning ordinance says "Vacation Rentals are prohibited uses on Sullivan's Island" (Sec. 21-117). A vacation rental is any rental or paid stay of less than 28 continuous days. In plain language:
- Rentals of 28 consecutive nights or more are allowed with a town business license. Anything shorter is not.
- A few older rentals can continue. Homes that were lawfully used as vacation rentals in the 12 months before November 21, 2000 are treated as nonconforming uses. They need a yearly certificate of zoning compliance and a vacation rental business license, a minimum stay of three nights, on-site parking for guests and a 24-hour contact.
- Those licenses do not transfer at sale. A new owner who wants to keep renting has to apply to the town within 30 days of the transfer, and a rental that goes 12 months without being used is treated as abandoned.
There is one open question. In February 2026 the Court of Appeals ruled 2 to 1, in an unpublished opinion, that a house owned by an LLC with up to eight member shares and managed by Pacaso was not a vacation rental under the town's definition, because the owners were not paying to stay (Court of Appeals, 2026-UP-078). A petition asking the South Carolina Supreme Court to review that ruling has been pending since June 2026 (docket 2026-001318), and the town has been discussing changes to its ordinance. If you are buying next door to a shared-ownership house, or thinking about one, ask me where this stands that week.
Design review, historic districts and what you can build
Sullivan's controls what gets built more tightly than most of Charleston, and it shows in the prices of the lots. The town's single-family district sets a minimum lot of one-half acre and a maximum height of 38 feet, and it caps a house's square footage and footprint in relation to the size of the lot (Sullivan's Island zoning, Article III). The town's Design Review Board, created in 2003, reviews new construction and renovations, can adjust some standards when a design is more compatible with the neighbors, and decides on a Certificate of Appropriateness for exterior work in the historic overlay districts. That includes new construction, demolition, fences, driveways and front yard landscaping (Town of Sullivan's Island, Design Review Board). If you are buying to renovate or rebuild, check whether the house is in a historic district or designated historic, and what the lot allows, before you write an offer.
Flood insurance
Because the town is in the NFIP and is CRS Class 5 on FEMA's October 2026 list, eligible NFIP policies can see up to a 25% CRS discount. That is not a guarantee of a particular premium. Flood insurance depends on the structure, the zone, the elevation certificate and the policy. Have your insurance advisor quote the address, and do not skip this step on a barrier island.
Sullivan's Island FAQs
What's the median home price on Sullivan's Island?
In 2026 YTD (January 1 to November 21, 2026), the median closed price on Sullivan's Island was $4,750,000 for all home types and $5,025,000 for houses only, from 35 closed sales (34 houses and one condo). Since January 2023, 146 homes have sold, with a median of $4,225,000.
Are Sullivan's Island home prices still going up?
The median is. The 2026 YTD median is $4,750,000, against $4,100,000 from January 1 to November 21, 2025. Price per square foot is about flat ($1,655 versus $1,642), so most of that gain comes from bigger, newer houses selling this year. Sales are up a little (35 versus 30) and closed volume is $206 million, the most of any year since 2023.
Is it a buyer's or seller's market?
Buyers have more room than they did in 2023. There are about 9.1 months of supply (28 active listings against about 3.1 sales a month), no 2026 sale closed over list price, and the median home took 58 days to sell. With so few sales, one listing at the right price can still move quickly.
Can I buy a home on Sullivan's Island and rent it short term?
Generally no. The town prohibits vacation rentals of fewer than 28 days. Rentals of 28 consecutive nights or more are allowed with a town business license. A small number of homes that were renting before November 2000 can continue under strict rules, but the license does not come with the house; a new owner has to apply within 30 days. A 2026 Court of Appeals ruling found that one co-ownership arrangement was not a vacation rental, and a request for Supreme Court review is pending.
Can I renovate, tear down or build new?
Yes, within the town's rules. The single-family district sets a half-acre minimum lot, a 38-foot height limit and square footage and footprint limits tied to lot size, and the Design Review Board reviews new construction and exterior changes, with a Certificate of Appropriateness required in the historic overlay districts. Check the lot and the house's historic status before you write an offer.
Which school will my kids go to?
The town lists Sullivan's Island Elementary, Laing Middle or Moultrie Middle, and Wando High. On the 2025-26 report cards, Sullivan's Island Elementary was rated Excellent (70), Laing Middle Excellent (64), Moultrie Middle Excellent (63) and Wando High Excellent (84). Confirm the address with the CCSD school lookup.
How much are property taxes?
In the Town of Sullivan's Island (Tax District 23), the 2026 millage is 275.0. The county estimator, using a $4,000,000 value, no stormwater, and the credits and $154 user fee it applies, came to about $16,682 at 4% and about $61,914 at 6%. Your bill depends on the assessed value, legal-residence status and the parcel. Use the county tax estimator for the address.
Do I need flood insurance?
Plan on looking at it, and do not skip an elevation certificate. Sullivan's Island is a barrier island in the NFIP, with a flood map effective January 29, 2021. FEMA's October 2026 list shows the town as CRS Class 5, which can mean up to 25% off eligible NFIP policies. Coverage and cost depend on the structure and the zone. Have the address quoted.
What is the accreted land, and does it affect my view?
It is the land that has built up in front of the original beachfront, much of it now maritime forest, which the town has kept in its natural state under a 1991 conservation easement. How much the town can trim it has been in court since 2010, and the South Carolina Supreme Court is now reviewing the latest ruling. If you are buying next to it, walk the path to the water and do not assume today's view is permanent.
How do you get on and off the island?
By the Ben Sawyer Bridge (SC 703) to Mount Pleasant or the Breach Inlet bridge to the Isle of Palms. From Town Hall, Google Maps' typical 8 a.m. weekday times were 9 to 16 minutes to Shem Creek (4.8 miles), 18 to 35 minutes to downtown (9.7 miles) and 24 to 40 minutes to the airport (18.5 miles). Summer weekends are slower, and the Ben Sawyer swing bridge sometimes opens for boats.
Watch more
- The Unexpected Pros and Cons of Living in Charleston, SC (starts at Sullivan's Island, 15:37). My take on Sullivan's next to Folly, inside the "A Version For Everyone" chapter. The beach towns comparison starts at 15:20.
- If I Had $1M in Charleston, I'd Move Here (4:24). Inside the south Mount Pleasant chapter: why living near Sullivan's Island, my favorite beach, costs more.
Sources
- CHS Regional MLS via Flexmls: closed single-family detached and attached sales in MLS area 43 (Sullivan's Island), January 1, 2023 to November 21, 2026; active listings on November 21, 2026.
- FEMA, CRS Eligible Communities, effective October 1, 2026: Town of Sullivan's Island, NFIP 455418, Class 5 (25%), current effective date 5/1/2017. FEMA Community Status Book: CID 455418B, current effective map date 01/29/21.
- Town of Sullivan's Island Zoning Ordinance, Article XIII, Vacation Rentals (Sec. 21-117 to 21-124) and Article III, RS Single Family District.
- S.C. Court of Appeals, Pacaso, Inc. v. Town of Sullivan's Island, Unpublished Opinion 2026-UP-078, filed Feb. 18, 2026. S.C. Supreme Court docket 2026-001318.
- S.C. Court of Appeals, Town of Sullivan's Island v. Bluestein, Opinion 6139, filed Feb. 25, 2026. S.C. Supreme Court docket 2026-001038.
- SiP Magazine, "Exploring The Forest On Our Doorsteps", Stratton Lawrence.
- Town of Sullivan's Island, Design Review Board and beach rules.
- Charleston County Auditor, 2026 millage and 2026 tax estimator, Tax District 23, $500,000 and $4,000,000 values, 4% and 6%, stormwater 0.
- Town of Sullivan's Island, schools. South Carolina Department of Education, 2025-26 Report Card Data for Researchers (school ratings) (checked Nov. 21, 2026). CCSD school lookup.
- National Park Service: Fort Moultrie and Charleston Light.
- Ben Sawyer Bridge drawbridge rules: 33 CFR Part 117, Subpart B.
- Google Maps typical drive times, departure 8:00 a.m. on Tuesday, November 24, 2026, from 2056 Middle St.
- Wikimedia Commons photographs credited in the captions (CC0, CC BY, CC BY-SA).
Photo credits: Wikimedia Commons images are used under the licenses shown in each caption (CC0, CC BY, CC BY-SA, or public domain).

Thinking about Sullivan's Island?
If you are buying, selling or trying to figure out whether Sullivan's or the Isle of Palms fits you better, I can walk the numbers with you, including what the lot allows, the flood questions and the accreted land on the specific address.
Set up a consultGentry Todd · The Gentry Todd Group at Compass · 843.730.4454